Context
- The Supreme Court has agreed to examine a petition by the All India Trade Union Congress (AITUC) challenging the constitutional validity of the definition of ‘industry’ under the Industrial Relations Code, 2020.
- The dispute centres on the Code’s exclusion of certain establishments from the definition, affecting access to industrial dispute remedies and worker protections.
Statutory framework
- The Industrial Relations Code, 2020 consolidates three laws:
- Trade Unions Act, 1926
- Industrial Employment (Standing Orders) Act, 1946
- Industrial Disputes Act, 1947
- It defines an industry as any systematic activity carried out through cooperation between employer and workers for the production, supply, or distribution of goods or services.
Exclusions under the Code
- Institutions owned or managed by organisations substantially engaged in charitable, social, or philanthropic activities.
- Government activities related to sovereign functions.
- Domestic services.
- Any other activity that the Central Government may notify at its discretion.
Grounds of constitutional challenge
1. Violation of Article 14
- The exclusions may violate the Right to Equality (Article 14) because they depend on who runs the establishment rather than the nature of work performed.
- Example: a nurse in a private commercial hospital and a nurse in a charitable hospital may do identical work, but the latter may be denied access to Industrial Tribunals and statutory dispute remedies.
2. Excessive delegation
- The Code allows the Central Government to notify additional excluded activities without expressly laying down limiting criteria.
- This raises concerns of arbitrary classification and excessive executive discretion.
3. Departure from judicial precedent
- The 2020 definition departs from Bangalore Water Supply and Sewerage Board v. A. Rajappa (1978).
- In that case, the Supreme Court laid down the triple test:
- Systematic activity;
- Cooperation between employer and employees;
- Production, supply, or distribution of goods or services.
- The Court held that the nature of the activity, not the employer’s identity or profit motive, determines whether an establishment is an ‘industry’.
Jai Bir Singh case (August 2026)
- The Supreme Court held that the Bangalore Water Supply triple test would continue to govern pending disputes under the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947.
- However, the Court clarified that the definition of ‘industry’ under Section 2(p) of the Industrial Relations Code, 2020 must be interpreted independently.
- This clarification makes the present constitutional scrutiny of the Code’s definition significant.
Impact on worker protections
- Workers in excluded establishments do not lose all legal rights.
- However, they are deprived of specific statutory protections under the Industrial Relations Code relating to:
- Retrenchment
- Lay-offs
- Closure
- Conciliation machinery for dispute resolution
Constitutional and legal significance
- Article 14: equality before law and equal protection of laws; classification must be reasonable and have a rational nexus with the objective.
- Article 19(1)(c): right to form associations or unions, relevant to collective bargaining and trade union rights.
- Article 43A (DPSP): steps to secure participation of workers in management of industries.
- Labour and industrial relations fall under the Concurrent List, enabling both Parliament and States to legislate.
Way forward
- Define exclusions with clear, objective criteria to avoid arbitrary classification.
- Balance labour welfare, industrial flexibility, and judicial review.
- Ensure consistency with Article 14 and established principles on excessive delegation.
- Provide effective dispute resolution and social security for workers in excluded establishments.