Why in News

  • The RBI Governor, addressing the 36th Conference of State Finance Secretaries, urged States to adopt prudent borrowing strategies and efficient cash management practices.
  • The focus was on maintaining long-term fiscal health amid rising debt-to-GSDP ratios, fiscal deficits, off-budget borrowings and high committed expenditure.

Key Facts and Data

  • Consolidated general government debt (Centre plus States) is around 81-85% of GDP; State government debt accounts for about one-third of this.
  • Aggregate State debt stood at 29.2% of GDP at end-March 2026, above the 20% prudence limit recommended by the FRBM Review Committee.
  • Punjab and West Bengal face severe fiscal stress with debt near or above 40% of GSDP.
  • Gujarat, Maharashtra and Odisha have contained debt-to-GSDP ratios within the 20% limit.
  • Kerala (35.5%) and Tamil Nadu (29.2%) have reduced outstanding liabilities by nearly 4-5 percentage points since 2021.
  • States' consolidated Gross Fiscal Deficit (GFD) is budgeted at 3.3% of GDP for FY 2025-26; 16 States budgeted GFD above the standard 3% limit.
  • States spend over 60% of revenue receipts on committed expenditure such as interest payments, salaries, pensions and subsidies.
  • States account for about two-thirds of total public spending and one-third of total revenue in India.
  • State capex is heavily supported by the Centre's 50-year interest-free loans under the SASCI scheme.

What Is Prudent Borrowing?

  • Prudent borrowing means limiting debt intake to long-term repayment capacity and ensuring borrowed funds are used efficiently.
  • The Golden Rule of Public Finance requires borrowing to be directed mainly toward Capital Expenditure (Capex) such as infrastructure, health and education, rather than Revenue Expenditure like administrative costs and non-merit subsidies.
  • It also involves aligning the borrowing calendar with actual cash-flow mismatches to avoid idle cash balances and unnecessary interest costs.

Significance

  • Macroeconomic stability: Prevents crowding out of private credit and keeps credit affordable for the private sector.
  • Fiscal space for welfare: Lower debt and interest obligations free resources for health, education and green transition.
  • Sovereign ratings: High debt-to-GDP ratios can keep sovereign ratings low and raise external borrowing costs for Indian corporates.
  • Inflation control: Unchecked deficits, especially if monetised, can create persistent inflation.
  • Intergenerational equity: Ensures current consumption is not financed by imposing an unsustainable burden on future generations.

Key Issues in State Borrowing

  • Off-budget borrowings: States bypass FRBM limits through State Public Sector Enterprises and Special Purpose Vehicles, often with State guarantees and weak legislative scrutiny.
  • Revenue versus capital expenditure: Borrowing for subsidies, loan waivers and freebies yields low or no future returns, unlike capex with a high fiscal multiplier of about 2.45.
  • Contingent liabilities: State guarantees to DISCOMs remain a fiscal risk if power distribution companies default.
  • Market volatility: Uncalibrated borrowing calendars can spike bond yields and disrupt monetary policy transmission.

Reform Measures Needed

  • Use Unified Lending Interface (ULI) and Programmable CBDC (P-CBDC) for targeted Direct Benefit Transfers and leak-proof welfare spending.
  • Strengthen State Level Bankers' Committees (SLBCs) for credit disbursement, priority sector lending and rural infrastructure financing.
  • Strictly follow State FRBM glide paths, typically capping fiscal deficit at 3-3.5% of GSDP.
  • Establish an independent Fiscal Council, as recommended by the 13th and 14th Finance Commissions and the N.K. Singh Committee (2016).
  • Cap off-budget borrowings by enforcing strict accounting standards; equating State off-budget borrowings with standard borrowing limits under Article 293(3) is a positive step.
  • Adopt RBI's Compendium on Cash and Debt Management, including Benchmark Issuance Strategy and better alignment of borrowings with expenditure needs.

Constitutional and Legal Context

  • Article 293 governs State borrowing; under Article 293(3), a State indebted to the Union needs Union Government consent for further loans.
  • The FRBM framework promotes fiscal stability through deficit and debt management, transparency and responsible borrowing.
  • The Finance Commission plays a key role in Centre-State financial relations and fiscal federalism.

Conclusion

Prudent borrowing does not mean zero borrowing. It means balancing debt for productive capital formation with avoidance of consumption-led debt traps. Institutionalising fiscal discipline and intergenerational equity is central to India's macroeconomic resilience during Amrit Kaal.