Introduction

  • The National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) recently took cognisance of allegations involving the use of children in a protest in Mumbai and directed an investigation into possible child rights violations.
  • The development highlights the NHRC's mandate to protect and promote human rights, while also drawing attention to its structural and practical limitations.

Establishment and Legal Status

  • The NHRC is a statutory body established on 12 October 1993 under the Protection of Human Rights Act, 1993.
  • It protects and promotes human rights relating to life, liberty, equality and dignity.
  • It is not a constitutional body; it derives its powers from an Act of Parliament.

Composition

  • Under Section 3 of the Act, the NHRC comprises a Chairperson, five full-time Members and seven deemed (ex-officio) Members.
  • The Chairperson must have been the Chief Justice of India or a Judge of the Supreme Court.
  • At least one of the three human rights experts must be a woman.

Appointment Process

  • The President appoints the Chairperson and Members on the recommendation of a six-member committee headed by the Prime Minister.
  • The committee includes the Lok Sabha Speaker, Union Home Minister, Deputy Chairman of the Rajya Sabha and Leaders of the Opposition in both Houses of Parliament.
  • The involvement of government officials in appointments has raised concerns about institutional autonomy.

Tenure

  • The Chairperson and Members hold office for three years or until the age of 70 years, whichever is earlier.
  • They are eligible for reappointment.

Functions and Powers

  • Inquire into human rights violations or negligence by public servants.
  • Intervene in court proceedings with the permission of the court.
  • Visit jails and other institutions to examine conditions.
  • Review legal safeguards for human rights.
  • Undertake research and promote human rights awareness.
  • During an inquiry, the NHRC has powers of a civil court, including summoning persons, requiring documents and obtaining relevant records.

Paris Principles

  • The NHRC is guided by the Paris Principles, which emphasise:
  • Independence
  • A broad human rights mandate
  • Adequate resources
  • Pluralism

Challenges

Limited Enforcement Powers

  • NHRC recommendations are advisory and non-binding.
  • It cannot directly punish violators or enforce compensation, leading to criticism that it is a toothless tiger.

Concerns over Independence

  • Government officials are involved in appointments and investigations.
  • This raises questions about the NHRC's autonomy, impartiality and transparency.

Lack of Diversity and Representation

  • Inadequate representation of women, minorities and civil society raises concerns about pluralism and inclusivity.

Accreditation Challenges

  • The Global Alliance of National Human Rights Institutions (GANHRI) recommended downgrading the NHRC's accreditation from A to B status in March 2025.
  • The appeal was rejected in December 2025, and the final accreditation review was deferred to November 2026.
  • The proposed downgrade had not been finalised as of October 2026.

Investigative Constraints

  • Dependence on government investigative agencies, including police personnel, raises conflict of interest concerns, especially in cases of alleged custodial violence and police misconduct.

Limited Jurisdiction

  • The NHRC generally cannot investigate alleged violations more than one year after their occurrence.
  • Its powers concerning violations involving the armed forces are restricted.
  • Under Section 19 of the Act, complaints involving the armed forces follow a special procedure: the Commission seeks a report from the Central Government before making recommendations.

Measures to Strengthen the NHRC

  • Strengthen enforcement powers: Amend the Protection of Human Rights Act, 1993 to ensure greater accountability and timely redressal.
  • Ensure institutional independence: Introduce transparent, merit-based appointments and reduce executive influence.
  • Promote diversity: Ensure representation of women, minorities, civil society and human rights experts.
  • Enhance investigative capacity: Establish an independent investigation mechanism and recruit trained personnel.
  • Expand jurisdiction: Review the one-year limitation and strengthen oversight in armed forces cases.
  • Strengthen resources and accountability: Provide adequate funding, skilled staff and modern technology.
  • Improve international compliance: Address GANHRI concerns to maintain credibility under the Paris Principles.
  • Better case management: Use digital systems and monitor Action Taken Reports.

Conclusion

  • The NHRC plays a vital role in safeguarding human rights and protecting vulnerable sections.
  • Strengthening its independence, investigative capacity, enforcement mechanisms and accountability is essential to uphold constitutional values, human dignity and the rule of law.

Exam Relevance

  • Prelims: Establishment, composition, appointment, tenure, powers, Paris Principles, GANHRI accreditation.
  • Mains: Role and limitations of statutory human rights institutions, institutional independence and accountability.