Context

  • Recent MLC elections have renewed debate on State Legislative Councils (Vidhan Parishads), the upper House in six states.
  • India permits either unicameral or bicameral state legislatures; only some states choose the latter.

Constitutional and Historical Background

  • Bicameralism at the Centre was introduced by the Montagu-Chelmsford Reforms, 1919; the Government of India Act, 1935 provided for bicameral legislatures in some provinces.
  • The first Legislative Council began functioning in Bengal in 1937.
  • Article 168: Defines the structure of state legislatures - unicameral or bicameral.
  • Article 169: Provides for creation or abolition of a Legislative Council. The State Legislative Assembly must pass a resolution by a special majority; Parliament then enacts a law by simple majority. This law is not a constitutional amendment under Article 368.
  • Article 171: Deals with composition, strength and election/nomination of members.

Strength and Tenure

  • Maximum strength: one-third of the total strength of the Legislative Assembly.
  • Minimum strength: 40 members.
  • The Council is a permanent body and is not subject to dissolution.
  • Members serve six-year terms; one-third retire every two years.
  • MLC eligibility age: 30 years (MLA: 25 years).

Composition and Election

  • 1/3rd: Elected by members of local bodies such as municipalities, Gram Panchayats, Panchayat Samitis and Zila Parishads.
  • 1/3rd: Elected by MLAs from persons who are not members of the Assembly.
  • 1/12th: Elected by graduates of three years standing residing in the state.
  • 1/12th: Elected by teachers with at least three years experience in educational institutions not below secondary standard.
  • 1/6th: Nominated by the Governor from persons with special knowledge or practical experience in literature, science, art, cooperative movement and social service.
  • MLC elections use proportional representation by means of a single transferable vote.

States with Legislative Councils

  • Six states currently have a Legislative Council: Andhra Pradesh, Telangana, Uttar Pradesh, Bihar, Maharashtra and Karnataka.
  • Jammu and Kashmir had a Council until the Jammu and Kashmir Reorganisation Act, 2019.

Utility of the Council

  • Acts as a revising chamber to check hasty or populist legislation.
  • Provides representation to diverse interests such as teachers, graduates and local bodies.
  • Allows nomination of experts and eminent persons who may avoid direct electoral politics.
  • Shares legislative workload by initiating non-financial bills.

Limitations and Criticism

  • Financial burden: maintaining a second House requires expenditure on salaries, allowances and infrastructure.
  • Parking lot criticism: often used to accommodate defeated politicians or coalition partners.
  • Limited legislative powers: under Article 197, it cannot veto an ordinary Bill and can delay it for a maximum of four months - three months initially and one month on reconsideration.
  • Money Bills: It cannot introduce or reject a Money Bill; it may recommend amendments within 14 days, which the Assembly may accept or reject.
  • No joint sitting: unlike Parliament under Article 108, state bicameral legislatures have no provision for a joint sitting to resolve deadlocks.
  • Delaying mechanism: critics say it can delay legislation without adding substantial value.
  • No federal imperative: unlike the Rajya Sabha, it does not represent states in a federal sense at the Union level.

Comparison: Rajya Sabha vs State Legislative Council

FeatureRajya SabhaState Legislative Council
Constitutional provisionsArticle 80Articles 169 and 171
ExistencePermanent constitutional body; cannot be abolishedCan be created or abolished by Parliament on a State Assembly resolution
StrengthMaximum 250Maximum one-third of Assembly; minimum 40
Nominated members12 by President1/6th by Governor
Presiding OfficerVice-President is ex-officio ChairmanChairman elected by Council members
DeadlockJoint sitting under Article 108No joint sitting
Electoral participationElected members vote for President; all vote for Vice-PresidentMembers do not vote in President or Vice-President elections

Exam Relevance

  • Prelims: Articles 168, 169, 171 and 197; composition; tenure; states; comparison with Rajya Sabha; Money Bill procedure.
  • Mains: utility and relevance of bicameralism in states; reform of Legislative Councils; fiscal burden versus representation; federalism and legislative efficiency.