Context
- World Day Against the Death Penalty is observed annually on 10 October; the 2026 theme is 'Stories for Life', focusing on individuals and families impacted by death row.
- The observance renews debate on India's capital punishment framework, the 'rarest of rare' doctrine, and the Supreme Court's push for fair procedure, individualized sentencing, and Article 21 safeguards.
Death Penalty in India: Legal Framework
- Capital punishment is the highest punishment under Indian criminal law. Life imprisonment is the rule; death penalty is the exception.
- Statutory requirement: Section 354(3) CrPC, 1973, now Section 393(3) BNSS, 2023, requires judges to record special reasons for awarding a death sentence.
- The Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS), 2023 retains capital punishment and extends it to offences such as mob lynching resulting in death and rape of a minor. Around 14 grave offences attract the death penalty.
- Bachan Singh v. State of Punjab (1980): A Constitution Bench upheld the death penalty but laid down the 'rarest of rare' doctrine — death sentence only when the alternative of life imprisonment is unquestionably foreclosed.
- Courts must balance aggravating circumstances (brutality/nature of crime) against mitigating circumstances (socio-economic, psychological, and reformative potential of the convict).
- Statutory exemptions: Juveniles (under 18 at the time of offence), pregnant women, and persons with mental illness cannot be executed.
- Appellate safeguards: A Sessions Court death sentence must be confirmed by the High Court; the convict can appeal to the Supreme Court.
- Clemency: Under Article 72 (President) and Article 161 (Governor), mercy petitions may seek pardon, reprieve, respite, or commutation.
- Curative petition: Recognized in Rupa Ashok Hurra v. Ashok Hurra (2002) as a final judicial remedy against gross miscarriage of justice.
Evolution of Due Process in Capital Sentencing
- Crime-centric era (1983–1995): Machhi Singh (1983) shifted focus toward the circumstances of the crime. Ravji v. State of Rajasthan (1995) wrongly held that the crime's gravity, not the criminal's circumstances, mattered most.
- Santosh Kumar Bariyar v. State of Maharashtra (2009): The Supreme Court declared Ravji per incuriam for ignoring Bachan Singh and clarified that life imprisonment is foreclosed only when the State proves reformation is unachievable.
- Manoj v. State of Madhya Pradesh (2022): Mandated psychological, psychiatric, prison conduct, and socio-economic background reports before imposing death penalty.
- Vasanta Sampat Dupare v. Union of India (2025): A rigorous, individualized sentencing hearing under the Manoj guidelines flows from Articles 14 and 21; a death sentence without such hearing is unconstitutional and can be reopened even after appeals.
- Waris v. State of Madhya Pradesh (2026): The Court commuted a death sentence because the State failed to exclude the possibility of reformation; extreme gravity of crime alone cannot foreclose life imprisonment.
Persistent Challenges
- Trial court non-compliance: Of 128 death sentences in 2025, an analysis of 83 cases found 79 (95.18%) failed to comply with Manoj safeguards. The Muzaffarnagar case (2026) raised similar concerns.
- Rushed sentencing: A study of 306 death sentences (2018–2020) found 36.1% pronounced on the same day as conviction and 18.4% the next day, denying meaningful mitigation evidence.
- High acquittal rates: Nearly one-third of death sentences reviewed by High Courts and the Supreme Court in the past decade ended in complete acquittal.
- Flawed investigations: In 2025, the Supreme Court acquitted accused in 10 out of 19 death penalty cases, citing poor investigations, opaque confessions, and doubtful forensic evidence.
- Socio-economic bias: Death row prisoners disproportionately belong to economically vulnerable backgrounds with limited access to competent legal representation.
International Human Rights Framework
- UDHR, 1948: Article 3 guarantees right to life; Article 5 prohibits torture and cruel, inhuman, or degrading punishment.
- ICCPR, 1966: Article 6 protects the right to life and restricts death penalty in retentionist states to the 'most serious crimes'. India is a party.
- Second Optional Protocol to ICCPR (1989): The only universal treaty aimed at total abolition; India is not a signatory.
- By end-2025, 145 countries had abolished the death penalty in law or practice.
Reform Measures
- 262nd Law Commission Report (2015): Recommended abolition for all crimes except terrorism-related offences and waging war against the State.
- Mitigation specialists: Create a state-funded cadre of independent social workers and psychologists to operationalize Manoj guidelines.
- Mercy petition timelines: Give statutory backing to Shatrughan Chauhan v. Union of India (2014) guidelines to prevent 'death row syndrome' due to executive delay.
- Mental illness exemption: Align BNSS, 2023 with UN ECOSOC Safeguards and CRPD to prohibit sentencing/execution of persons with severe mental health or intellectual disabilities.
- Intermediate sentencing: Use alternatives such as imprisonment for the remainder of natural life without remission, as adopted in Waris (2026).
Conclusion
- The constitutionality of the death penalty depends on procedural fairness, reformation opportunities, and Article 21 safeguards, not retributive public outrage. India must strengthen mitigation frameworks and ensure capital sentencing remains guided by constitutional principles.